Mindat Logo

Jeffrey Weissman's Blog

Interesting Mineral Quality Statistics

5th Oct 2009

I wanted to determine how many minerals are "collectable" by my standards - that is, I can see nice crystals in a microscope without squinting too hard.

Conclusion - only 60% of known minerals qualify.

Comments:
Some minerals, such as purpurite, do not occur in crystals, but can also be considered collectable as they occur in nice hand-sized specimens, but I did not breakdown the "V" catagory for this possibility. "M" minerals require a high magnification optical microscope or a electron microscope in order to observe them. Most "U" minerals are new or recent, and so have not had abstracts or descriptions published.

By and large, older (DANA) minerals are more likely to be well crystallized, as reflected in that fact that almost all of them with IMA "G" status are classified as either V or X in quality, with almost 80% X. Only 50% of newer minerals, discovered in the last 50 years or so, since the IMA started approving new mineral names, are crystallized. This is clearly a reflection on our ability to find and document smaller and smaller mineral grains.



Grandfathered minerals – 27.9%
of these
X – 78.6 %
V – 20.9 %
M – 0.4 %
U – 0.1 %

Minerals with approved status - 65.0%
of these:
X – 51.0 %
V – 39.4 %
M – 5.4 %
U – 4.2 %

All minerals, including grandfathered, approved, redefined
X – 60.0 %
V – 33.4 %
M – 3.7 %
U – 2.9%

Definitions:
X - crystallized – reported to be found in crystals at least 0.03 cm
V - visible – reported to found in grains of at least 0.01 cm
M - microscopic – not crystallized or visible
U – unknown – not report found




Blog has been viewed at least 788 times.

Comments

Interesting statistics, Jeff.

Your "best" category includes all crystals bigger than 0.3mm, so just barely visible shape to the naked eye. Do you have any idea on the number of species occuring as crystals at least 1 cm size, so things that would be of interest to TN collectors and other non-micromounters? I'll take a wild guess and say between 10 and 15% of all known species, but I haven't tried to count them.

regards,
Alfredo

Alfredo Petrov
13th Oct 2009 9:18pm
Alfredo - I did not classify by size, you are probably right in that only about 10% are "cabinet worthy"

Jeffrey Weissman
15th Oct 2009 9:30pm

In order to leave comments to this blog post, you must be registered
Mineral and/or Locality
Google
 
www.mindat.org Web
Copyright © Jolyon Ralph and Ida Chau 1993-2009. Site Map. Locality, mineral & photograph data are the copyright of the individuals who submitted them.Further information contact the Site hosted & developed by Jolyon Ralph. Mindat.org is an online information resource dedicated to providing free mineralogical information to all. Mindat relies on the contributions of hundreds of members and supporters. If you would like to add information to improve the quality of our database, then click here to register. Current server date and time: 24th Nov 2009 07:00:45