Home PageAbout MindatThe Mindat ManualHistory of MindatCopyright StatusWho We AreContact UsAdvertise on Mindat
Donate to MindatCorporate SponsorshipSponsor a PageSponsored PagesMindat AdvertisersAdvertise on Mindat
Learning CenterWhat is a mineral?The most common minerals on earthInformation for EducatorsMindat ArticlesThe ElementsThe Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryGeologic Time
Minerals by PropertiesMinerals by ChemistryAdvanced Locality SearchRandom MineralRandom LocalitySearch by minIDLocalities Near MeSearch ArticlesSearch GlossaryMore Search Options
The Mindat ManualAdd a New PhotoRate PhotosLocality Edit ReportCoordinate Completion ReportAdd Glossary Item
Mining CompaniesStatisticsUsersMineral MuseumsClubs & OrganizationsMineral Shows & EventsThe Mindat DirectoryDevice SettingsThe Mineral Quiz
Photo SearchPhoto GalleriesSearch by ColorNew Photos TodayNew Photos YesterdayMembers' Photo GalleriesPast Photo of the Day GalleryPhotography
╳Discussions
💬 Home🔎 Search📅 LatestGroups
EducationOpen discussion area.Fakes & FraudsOpen discussion area.Field CollectingOpen discussion area.FossilsOpen discussion area.Gems and GemologyOpen discussion area.GeneralOpen discussion area.How to ContributeOpen discussion area.Identity HelpOpen discussion area.Improving Mindat.orgOpen discussion area.LocalitiesOpen discussion area.Lost and Stolen SpecimensOpen discussion area.MarketplaceOpen discussion area.MeteoritesOpen discussion area.Mindat ProductsOpen discussion area.Mineral ExchangesOpen discussion area.Mineral PhotographyOpen discussion area.Mineral ShowsOpen discussion area.Mineralogical ClassificationOpen discussion area.Mineralogy CourseOpen discussion area.MineralsOpen discussion area.Minerals and MuseumsOpen discussion area.PhotosOpen discussion area.Techniques for CollectorsOpen discussion area.The Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryOpen discussion area.UV MineralsOpen discussion area.Recent Images in Discussions
Techniques for Collectorssolubility HCl vs water
27th Dec 2013 11:58 UTCcascaillou
I used to think that if a mineral is soluble in water then it is necessarly also soluble in strong acid solutions (as these are water based), and reciprocally that a mineral that isn't soluble in strong acid solution cannot be soluble in water...
However I came across this documentation about solubility of minerals: http://www.mindat.org/article.php/553/Solubility+Data+on+646+Common+and+Not+So+Common+Minerals
This table shows that many minerals that are soluble in water still aren't soluble in HCl.
How is that possible, considering that concentrated HCl solutions (such as 37%) are largely composed of water?
27th Dec 2013 13:27 UTCAlfredo Petrov Manager
Imagine if weather forecasters were not permitted to give us the temperature and were only allowed to use the words "hot" and "cold" :-S
Then there are the minerals that react with HCl to give an insoluble precipitate...
In conclusion, such a table is of only very limited use without numerical data.
27th Dec 2013 15:27 UTCcascaillou
Of course one shouldn't expect all minerals to solubilize within minutes, but keeping things at human size time wise, I always wait for 24h of soaking in the solvent before concluding that a compound is insoluble.
For a solubility test, I only use a tiny grain of the mineral (I mean 1 or 2mm sized grain), soaked in an excess of concentrated acid (meaning filling a good quarter of the test tube with solvent). Indeed a single tiny grain makes it easy to observe even slight dissolution over a 24h period.
Concerning acid concentration, I just stick to the highest concentration available to the general public (i.e. at the hardware store)
In the final, you don't really need to obtain numerical values (i.e. mg per liter) as long as your empirical solubility test is based on a standardized procedure.
Anyway, I still don't understand how a mineral compound that is soluble in water could be insoluble in a solution of hydrochloric acid???
Assuming that the acid solution is used in excess and that both experiments were conducted at ambient room temperature, and considering that an HCl solution is largely composed of water, I would expect the mineral to show at least the same solubility in the acid than in water, if not better.
So is that a mistake in the table, or is there some chemistry rule I'm not aware of that can explain such results?
27th Dec 2013 17:14 UTCDoug Daniels
As far as the table, I perused thru the"k's", and have these observations:
Borax and kernite - borates - would react with acid to form boric acid, which isn't soluble in cold solution, so may be part of the explanation
Carnallite, halite, kainite - chlorides (I think kainite is a chloride) - there's some rule in chemistry regarding same anions - HCl wouldn't necessarily dissolve a chloride, because of the common ion effect (or at least has something to do with it - the chemists can chime in here)
Chalcanthite, copiapite, epsomite - sulfates - may have to do with common ion effect also. Maybe they were just ornery at the time.
Also, may have to do with the concentration of acid used; don't know if that is given in the table. I haven't physically tried to dissolve chalcanthite or epsomite with HCl (either dilute or straight from the hardware-store bottle) to see if they dissolve....maybe that's how I'll spend New Years eve. Anyway, my 2 cents worth.
27th Dec 2013 17:21 UTCDavid Von Bargen Manager
http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/je60084a015
27th Dec 2013 19:18 UTCRock Currier Expert
27th Dec 2013 22:17 UTCTrevor Dart
It comes back to solute vs solvent. In acidic conditions there can be a negative effect on the solubility of some substances (as previously pointed out with borax) if the concentration of Hydrogen ions is already high. This would then show a tendency not to dissolve in acid when the same substance had limited solubility in water.
Again the key factor in solubility is temperature. If the water is hotter, then it has a greater ability to act as a solvent. (gases on the other hand have greater solubility in cold water). The dissolving of substances in acidic solutions is usually a chemical reaction involving the hydrogen ions and this may be the data that is being relayed in this table. A substance may dissolve in water, but have no apparent reaction with the HCl.
Just remember that water will dissolve quartz. But the temperature needs to be around 300+ oC and at a high pressure. Which is why it commonly forms in hydrothermal veins and at hot springs.
Trev
27th Dec 2013 22:52 UTCcascaillou
It does indeed confirm that while NaCl (=halite) is soluble in water (1g dissolves in 2.8mL water at 25°C), HCl decreases its solubility in water, to the point that NaCl is almost insoluble in concentrated HCl (that suggest that NaCl is soly in diluted HCl but to a lesser extent than in water)
Please note that a solubility test might help to identify a mineral by elimination of other candidates, it's largely empirical, and for such purpose, the fact that almost everything is soluble in water isn't an argument. We are talking of a tiny mineral grain in an excess of solvant, at ambiant pressure and ambiant temperature, or heating around 100°C, duration of experiment not exceeding 24h. Upon such specifications, neither quartz nor calcite are going to noticeably dissolve in water, and therefore mineralogy books state that these are insoluble in water (even so they would indeed dissolve with time/pressure/heat).
28th Dec 2013 15:02 UTCIlkka Mikkola
most phosphates are soluble in 37% HCl but many Al- and Be-phosphates are not soluble in 10% HCl.
Of course they are theoretically soluble but after 1-3 hours they look intact. We have used 10% HCl for identifying
viitaniemiite. Fluorapatite at Viitaniemi could be very much like viitaniemiite but it is soluble in 10% HCl.
28th Dec 2013 15:19 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
I'd like to see an ASTM-style procedural description for how to run a solubility test. Once this is done, and tried and tested, we can have a even play field to discuss solubility characteristics. Only then does solubility become a meaningful test for the masses.
Not sure I want to lead this project, but I would if there was enough interest.
28th Dec 2013 15:34 UTCcascaillou
Also, I don't understand why mineralogy handbooks often mention solubility in acids, but never solubility in bases (which would be just as useful information).
Another concern is that concentration of solution is never mentionned.
This being said, it would make more sense to stick to the highest concentration available to the general public, meaning at the hardware store, not through chemical suppliers (and anyway I do not like to deal with 90%+ HNO3 or H2SO4 which are nasties)
28th Dec 2013 19:39 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
And even with a standardized procedure, the solubility results won't necessarily be perfect. What if you're testing something which is a mixture, and one component dissolves in (for example) hydrochloric acid but another does not?
28th Dec 2013 23:21 UTCIlkka Mikkola
That is the point. If the HCl is strong (undiluted), I think that all phosphates dissolve.
Does anyone use diluted (about 10%) HCl with calcite identification?
28th Dec 2013 23:27 UTCRock Currier Expert
29th Dec 2013 01:02 UTCReiner Mielke Expert
29th Dec 2013 01:53 UTCcascaillou
For instance a standard of 90% for H2SO4 would be very impractical (only chemical suppliers have it for sale), on the other hand I guess that any hardware store selling H2SO4 for batteries will be offering it at 30% at least (or most likely higher concentration), so 30% might be a reasonable standard for H2SO4, in terms of supply I mean.
Btw, if the label is announcing 35% concentration but the product is actually 32% only, are those 3% error actually going to make a big difference in a solubility test?
ps: concerning Mohs hardness, beside that it is empirical and approximative, it would be nice to advice people not to work from rough samples of reference material, I've seen a lot of hardness test kits composed of rough pieces of each mineral of the mohs scale. Quartz is 7 and orthoclase is 6, but I still have to see one producing a visible scratch on a rough cleaved feldspar (messy step like cleavage) with a quartz point. I think one should only work with flat piece of POLISHED reference material.
29th Dec 2013 03:10 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
Mindat.org is an outreach project of the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy, a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: March 29, 2024 06:47:41
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: March 29, 2024 06:47:41