Home PageAbout MindatThe Mindat ManualHistory of MindatCopyright StatusWho We AreContact UsAdvertise on Mindat
Donate to MindatCorporate SponsorshipSponsor a PageSponsored PagesMindat AdvertisersAdvertise on Mindat
Learning CenterWhat is a mineral?The most common minerals on earthInformation for EducatorsMindat ArticlesThe ElementsThe Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryGeologic Time
Minerals by PropertiesMinerals by ChemistryAdvanced Locality SearchRandom MineralRandom LocalitySearch by minIDLocalities Near MeSearch ArticlesSearch GlossaryMore Search Options
The Mindat ManualAdd a New PhotoRate PhotosLocality Edit ReportCoordinate Completion ReportAdd Glossary Item
Mining CompaniesStatisticsUsersMineral MuseumsClubs & OrganizationsMineral Shows & EventsThe Mindat DirectoryDevice SettingsThe Mineral Quiz
Photo SearchPhoto GalleriesSearch by ColorNew Photos TodayNew Photos YesterdayMembers' Photo GalleriesPast Photo of the Day GalleryPhotography
╳Discussions
💬 Home🔎 Search📅 LatestGroups
EducationOpen discussion area.Fakes & FraudsOpen discussion area.Field CollectingOpen discussion area.FossilsOpen discussion area.Gems and GemologyOpen discussion area.GeneralOpen discussion area.How to ContributeOpen discussion area.Identity HelpOpen discussion area.Improving Mindat.orgOpen discussion area.LocalitiesOpen discussion area.Lost and Stolen SpecimensOpen discussion area.MarketplaceOpen discussion area.MeteoritesOpen discussion area.Mindat ProductsOpen discussion area.Mineral ExchangesOpen discussion area.Mineral PhotographyOpen discussion area.Mineral ShowsOpen discussion area.Mineralogical ClassificationOpen discussion area.Mineralogy CourseOpen discussion area.MineralsOpen discussion area.Minerals and MuseumsOpen discussion area.PhotosOpen discussion area.Techniques for CollectorsOpen discussion area.The Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryOpen discussion area.UV MineralsOpen discussion area.Recent Images in Discussions
Techniques for CollectorsCleaning Pyrite
18th Jun 2010 03:52 UTCArt
I was searching online and I found this thread of messages regarding someone asking "how to clean pyrite." I design jewelry in New York City, for a small company, and we have just finished production on necklaces using PYRITE beads. The goods have been shipped, but not on retail stores yet, and the customer, in dismay, reported that the beads left a blackish soot on her t-shirt. I had one of our employees wear it for a few hours, and she got it too. I need help, desperately.
I believe the pyrite beads are from China. What is this soot? If I clean the pyrite beads, will it still continue to happen? Does this mean the beads are just dirty, or have traces of acid, or is this a naturally-occurring substance.
I personally thank anyone who can help, even if just ideas. We are a small jewelry company in the garment district, and one of the very few who still manufacture in the US. This problem can potentially damage our business. I dont know how this blog/e-group works, but please email me too at art@veloira.com for your response.
Thank you VERY much,
Art
18th Jun 2010 08:41 UTCRock Currier Expert
First of all, are you sure your beads are of pyrite or perhaps rather marcasite? Often Chinese suppliers do not know for sure what it is that they are selling or will give it a name they think has more sex appeal. The chances are that they are pyrite because it is a very common mineral but it is something you should keep in mind especially dealing with Chinese suppliers. Pyrite is not the most stable mineral and will in time tarnish and loose its luster. Pyrite also has the bad habit of producing "black dust" when it rubs together. The black dust is just finely divided particles of pyrite that look black. It may be something as simple as the beads rubbing together that is creating the black dust. Do you have spacers between the beads that prevent them rubbing together? If not, the addition of spacers or big knots may cut down a lot on the "black dust".
18th Jun 2010 09:26 UTCJolyon Ralph Founder
Pyrite isn't one of the best materials to use in jewellery.
Jolyon
18th Jun 2010 16:24 UTCDonald Slater
19th Jun 2010 02:29 UTCArt
I also read in an earlier thread, to use lime away to clean them? And also, "chinese powder?" (whatever this is :-). What are your thoughts on that idea?
19th Jun 2010 22:46 UTCRock Currier Expert
20th Jun 2010 16:35 UTCAnonymous User
I believe the dust is pyrite powder resulted from the polishing.It could also result from rubbing to each other,but this may take more time to appear on a shirt,I think.As Rock and Jaylon suggested,leave spaces (with knots)between the beads and before putting them together give each bead an ultrasonic bath.
Let your clients know they shouldn't clean the necklace with water too often if they want to preserve it for longer without having the beads broken.
Hope that helps!
-Kostas.
7th Mar 2012 02:16 UTCPam
6th Jun 2012 17:52 UTCSherry Pollock
In the photo I attached of my beads, you can see that they have blackened over time. However, what I'm more concerned about is the crystallization present on some of the beads. I realize that it's likely oxidation resulting from the mineral's iron and sulfur chemical composition. Has anyone else experienced this? Do you think the Lime-Away would remove this as well without irreparably damaging the beads?
And Pam, if you figure out a way to coat the beads to prevent/cut-down on the tarnishing, I'd love to know too!!
Thanks again!
Sherry
7th Jun 2012 00:38 UTCPeter Haas
7th Jun 2012 20:18 UTCRock Currier Expert
15th Mar 2013 17:52 UTCJan Burch
As a jewelry designer, I believe that the simplicity of maintenance (hopefully none is needed!) is just as important as the continued beauty of the piece, and reasonable price point. Right-these are the big three?
Further cleaning of pyrite is a great idea during manufacturing (if it cuts out future black). The application of laquer is something to think about. Lacquer is used often in UK for jewelry. I think some lacquers are better than others and know that sometimes pieces need to be re-lacquered.
Anybody here from the UK? Jan Burch
15th Mar 2013 17:58 UTCJan Burch
20th Mar 2013 23:21 UTCSandy
21st Mar 2013 11:51 UTCReiner Mielke Expert
21st Apr 2013 17:34 UTCNan Sawyer
22nd Apr 2013 17:54 UTCTim Jokela Jr
Search this website for pyrite / marcasite disease and the stabilization method proposed by Reiner Mielke. It's very easy, requires nothing more than water, WD-40, motor oil, and a bit of time.
I have used it on a sulfide specimen so rotten that it was soft enough to break bits off with nothing but finger pressure, upon which a half dozen alteration minerals had grown in the decades since it was collected, and enough sulfuric acid had formed to burn thru the cardboard box and stain the drawer bottom.
The treatment was a few months ago, there's no evidence of alteration since then, but I won't call it a success until a few years have passed. Reiner has treated some very unstable marcasite crystals, decades ago, and they're as nice as the day they were collected, so I'm pretty confident it's a winner. Any non-believers out there, get cracking on your pyrite/marcasites before it's too late. Believe it or not, the specimen does not look oiled, or smell bad... I highly recommend the Mielke Method!
So, you can indeed preserve your jewelry pyrite, but, the bad news is, it probably won't last if you continue to wear it. Skin acids, sweat, atmospheric moisture, etc., will slowly attack and alter it.
Some sort of surface coating is conceivable, but I'm not sure if there's anything out there that's been proven to pass the test of time. Perhaps further research into the consolidants used by paleontologists, like Vinac, would bear fruit; fossil and artifact preservation is a big field, they're highly advanced. Of course, if you've done the Mielke Method, then you'll have problems with adhesion of most coatings, unless you clean all the oil off, which removes the protection....
Long story short.... chuck the stuff and don't buy any more jewelry made from pyrite or marcasite.
23rd Apr 2013 19:37 UTCJohn Oostenryk
re: specimen saving- http://www.mindat.org/forum.php?read,19,149266,page=4
I was quite disgusted when I read Reiner's proposed method with oiling. Good God- that sounds like a complete mess! The guy is crazy...
BUT- after realizing a local connection between oil/bitumin pockets associated with long exposed and completely intact marcasite crystals... and therefore, some later related reflection... I resolved to engage in an ongoing product test with various control groups running.
I only used th WD-40, I couldn't bring myself to do the glooping oil factor...
However, I believe I am at a year and a half and nooothing is changing on my marcasite/pyrite pcs... So good news so far...
...Further details in a separate post are pending...
~JO:)
23rd Apr 2013 21:11 UTCMaggie Wilson Expert
John... could you clarify something? When you write what you said about Reiner, you mean those were your initial thoughts, yes? And now you think maybe, not so much?
I think it would be a good idea to retract, or at the very least, qualify your remarks. On both threads.
Please. And thanks.
Maggie (That's Mrs. Reiner Mielke to you, buddy!) Wilson
23rd Apr 2013 21:53 UTCRock Currier Expert
23rd Apr 2013 22:48 UTCJohn R. Montgomery 🌟 Expert
No matter if he is starting to agree, he should apologize to Reiner for uncalled for offensive language.
John M.
23rd Apr 2013 23:44 UTCJohn Oostenryk
Several things to report for you:)
First- I certainly respect you! I have always enjoyed your friendly, positive, and detailed comments. I’m very serious about that and I do value your presence on Mindat!
2) AH-- I knew you were associated with Reiner- now I know how;) You DO know him!
I am very honest, and so I also understand righteous dismay(yours.) Very sorry about that!
I absolutely meant no disrespect, nor trolling, nor anger or anything negative at all!
I have ammended both posts to hopefully more clearly convey myself. I had posted to both threads so that the initial good news would be found in both places.
Really, I thought it was quite innocuous, as it was as anecdote about myself and learning- not about Reiner per se.
That said- well yes, I thought he was something, bizarre maybe! Of course, then, when he first posted, there was a long list of replies, (where I was silent!) which poked fun and refutation. ( I loved the squeaky pyrite one- that was funny!)
Lets not go on about what was simply intended as a humorous anecdote about ME, not him.
An old tune comes to mind, as Steve Winwood sang, ”…at the time I really felt that way, but that was then and now it’s today…”
(I changed my mind right? …and yes, I was laughing at myself as I was dipping my test specimens thinking, dang this is soo gross:)
As Rock noted (Correct Sir!) I really intended nothing but to add support to the utilization of the concept, wacky as it may sound… Don’t knock it till ya try it~ nuff said.
I do plan a written report for the Mindat community in support of the process where I will relate my findings with the local materials here. I’m honestly excited about getting that positive information out to people.
Of course, my support is just a short term data relay. Hopefully, replication of Reiner’s results will be across the board as to locales and duration… Time will tell:)
Sincerely,
~John O:)
24th Apr 2013 00:05 UTCJohn Oostenryk
I do agree with the positive applications! I didn't really worry about being 'branded as being in the crazy camp' :0
I say that with simple humor intended- poking fun at myself!
There was no insult intended and I believe I have ammended the misunderstanding adequately.
Hope you understand-Have a good day:)
~JO:)
24th Apr 2013 01:43 UTCReiner Mielke Expert
Trouble with just WD40 is that it will eventually evaporate and you will be back to square one. Of course you can always reapply the WD40 but it stinks! Believe it or not motor oil does not smell nearly as badly as WD40 and lasts forever ( eventually converting to tar). I also came up with the idea of using oil because I noticed that marcasite associated with hydrocarbons are much shinier and less "weathered". Besides that the chemistry makes sense, no sulphide can oxidize under reducing conditions which the oil provides. Also the mess that pyrite disease makes is a lot worse than a bit of motor oil.
24th Apr 2013 03:24 UTCJohn Oostenryk
Regarding the oil factor- Funny thing that! It was today, after Tim's post assured me of the nonresidual state, and I was sorting my reply issue, it kinda clicked that oil would 'fix' that 'light aromatics evaporation' issue that results in the prolonged odor from WD-40. Thanks for the confirmation.
I also concur- WD-40 does eventually dissipate totally- which would necessitate further application- just like any'protectant'. Whereas, as you say, the oil finishes the situation... Priorly, I just hadn't been able to take/make the full "leap of faith" with the heavier(than wd40) oil. It is pending,LOL.
I am currently drip drying after the WD-40 a batch of material that was a basketball size chunk of 100% intergrown stalactitic Linwood Mine marcasite. The decomp odor was really strong in some areas- so correct in nothing to lose:) Dang is it crazy intricate!
Incredibly complex, porous intergrowth. Within the innumerable openings, are innumerable small to tiny scaleno calcites... Its sorta like looking at a human vascular system replaced by a dripping and xtlizng FeS2...
The problem has occurred in past, in some more densely packed pieces where the water rinse leaves water trapped behind some calcite growth, and then oxidation converts to rusting stains. It definitely trashes the appearance, and while I see no way to fully get away from the entrapment, trying anyway! This big chunk already was majorly contacted throughout (how big was the parent???)from blasting. I ran it through a trimmer to open it up more for draining(Pieces are still big.) I have used a space heater set on high to flash as much water off before immersing in WD-40. Interesting too, no thermal damage to the calcites observed so far. (I wouldn't try this stunt on anything you weren't will to lose...) My thinking was hot water for final soak/rinse which promotes evap, then to hot dry air to continue the evap, aided by heat expansion of openings, which would possibly also allow some improved penetration for WD-40 next. Granted, that is prolly just positive thinking(coefficient of expansion being pretty tiny and of nanoshort duration when 'quenched' by the oil).
That initial trapped rusting on this batch, was very minimal compared to volume of success. More results as they become evident.
This will be a part of my 'proposed' and no doubt ridiculously long in images, lil report on your process~
Anyone want some INSANE stalactic/xtline camera fodder, micro/thmb Marcasite xtls? PM me for trades or whatall. It HAS been fun monkeying with it so far! Nuff bout that portion...
My correlation epiphany came from material from the southern edge of UMV type deposits just N of me. First portion was that the crystals were in exposed vugs in rock that was being immersed repeatedly for extended periods by extra scummy flood waters of the Mississippi River. That rock was dumped over 20 years ago. Anything below flood level that was unstable was just a reddish stain... And then there would be a cluster of stable xtls! WTH? Occasionally there would be gooey bitumin on rocks. I thought it was sloppy seal coat asphalt from the adjacent road, till splitting a boulder produced both gooey tar and light oil, with a nice pyrite cluster inside it! That got the seed to growing on hows and whys... It was timely that you had recently described your successful application... Following all that, I happened to make a huge find of intergrown pyrite and marcasite from a clay deposit in a regional quarry. I had a ridiculous quantity to sort out and THAT was when I decided to test the idea in full. I had mostly stable stuff, but some was clearly bad and some was shifting... So plenty of guinea pigs!
I guess you could say the rest of the story is becoming 'history', the WHOLE good kind, and not the disintegrated BAD kind...
Yes, obviously, in retrospect, your hypothesis on reduction and environment do make sense:) Good stuff!
More details eventually of course...
Thanks!
~JO:)
27th Apr 2013 18:55 UTCD Mike Reinke
You mention 'marcasite association w/ hydrocarbons' made a light finally go off in my brain-duuuh! I've seen that. Walking the Lake Michigan beaches, there are lots of rocks that have small cavities of oil in them, or drier tar. A few years ago I picked up a softball sized broken rock w/ a pyrite lined cavity, but solid with tar. I recently cleaned the smaller chip, and it is lined with dazzling blades of marcasite. I gave the bigger chunk to a friend for his yard, now I need it back!
But how do you clean out the tar? I soaked it in gasoline, WD40, simple green, hot water, a few other chemicals, yes, it stinks, and it took a long time. Soaking overnight only made slow progress each night. Is there an easier way? Doesn't sound like it...
John, your stuff sounds cool. I may be out your way next month-ish! Can't plan anything right now...
Mike
29th Apr 2013 19:01 UTCTim Jokela Jr
2nd Jul 2013 10:21 UTCFeanne
28th Jan 2014 18:02 UTCLindaluv
I decided not to purchase before researching pyrite - being "buyer beware".
Is there any further/recent news regarding the prevention of oxidization/decomposition with e.g. Lacquer??
Also, would a coat of clear nail polish qualify as lacquer?
Thanks for any advice.
Appreciating the comments above.
cheers,
Linda :)-D
28th Jan 2014 19:21 UTCEd Clopton 🌟 Expert
Something else I haven't seen mentioned in this particular thread is that susceptibility to "pyrite disease" seems to depend in part on crystal grain size. Deterioration seems to happen on the surfaces of, or at boundaries between, individual crystal grains. Well-crystallized material consisting of one or a few crystal domains has less crystal surface area available to chemical attack, whereas massive material consisting of a multitude of tiny crystal grains has much greater surface area in a given volume. Therefore a single-crystal cube of Spanish pyrite should be relatively stable, but a cubic bead of the same size cut from similar polycrystalline material (or a fossil replaced by tiny pyrite grains) is much more vulnerable to deterioration. A great many of the beautiful pyrite "sunflower" concretions unearthed during construction at the Dallas-Fort Worth Airport in the early 1970s, and similar specimens from many other places, have disintegrated. The big cubic crystals around the edges survived individually, but the concretions were destroyed as the finer-grained centers deteriorated, swelled, and broke apart.
29th Jan 2014 18:07 UTCJohn Oostenryk
A) I guess everyone figured if Feanne didn't take the time to read the whole thread- no sense in bothering to reply! Ditto myself back then...
B) Hi Lindaluv! You read through~ You get a reply! LOL
You weren't clear on whether this was a completely ground/polished piece- or a 'freeform' cab with natural crystals exhibited and a ground back/sides/ whatever... Either way though... Hard telling as to longterm stability!? Sorry- the answer is there isn't a definite one...
My gut tells me- it will likely tarnish at some point at best. You make the call on cost vs utility. $5 and you wore it sometimes for a year??? Cool! $20 and a year?? ...That's your call.... Doubt it is something that will be passed down as heirloom.
The "marcasite' 1920's jewelry doesn't look as blingy today as back then. But that stuff, if whole now- it will probably stay that way...
Yes clear nail polish could be considered modern laquer.
It would surely prevent the dark ruboff if applied to back side(of a nat cab)~ it would help with same on finished piece, but would look funky painted over crystals though, IMHO....
HOWEVER- As stated in thread repeatedly-Might? slow issues but is NOT a cure~ IF it is "gonna go bad". BUT- you can stop that decomp with the oil treatment as stated above. I am 100% sure on that.
You will have a greasy spot on your blouse though- Not good!;)-
I'd pass on that jewelry option! Buy a blingy specimen-set it in a sunny spot! Treat it if it starts to act funny- Keep on enjoying it!
~JO:)
ps: Argh- I still haven't written up my continuing-ongoing marcasite preservation experiment... stupid promise... darn report... LOL
Maybe after Tucson2014... Looks like I am heading that way?! YAY... Maybe during the drive as passenger:)
Don't hold your breath-but eventually!
24th Feb 2014 21:45 UTCRock Currier Expert
3rd Feb 2018 17:40 UTCStephanie Ah
Newbie here. I have tried various search terms, but can't locate your post about cleaning pyrites/marcasites with wd40/or oil. Would you mind posting the link? (if allowed) Very interested in reading about that.
Thanks in advance,
Stephanie
3rd Feb 2018 19:56 UTCReiner Mielke Expert
3rd Feb 2018 20:03 UTCLuca Baralis Expert
3rd Feb 2018 20:08 UTCReiner Mielke Expert
5th Feb 2018 23:26 UTCStephanie Ah
I didn't want to mar the surface by scrubbing or rubbing it. Which is why I stumbled on this thread. I have all fingers crossed that this treatment will get rid of that slight deposit and give me my "gold ingot".
Mindat.org is an outreach project of the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy, a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: April 25, 2024 00:12:13
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: April 25, 2024 00:12:13