Are you sure you want to report this post?
You may optionally give an explanation for why this post was reported, which will be sent to the moderators along with the report. This can help the moderator to understand why you reported the post.
Posted by: Rick Dalrymple
I have agate nodules that have formed in shale--directly. They are clearly not formed from volcanic ash or even under an ash.
Why do you think they can only for as a result of vulcanism?