Home PageAbout MindatThe Mindat ManualHistory of MindatCopyright StatusWho We AreContact UsAdvertise on Mindat
Donate to MindatCorporate SponsorshipSponsor a PageSponsored PagesMindat AdvertisersAdvertise on Mindat
Learning CenterWhat is a mineral?The most common minerals on earthInformation for EducatorsMindat ArticlesThe ElementsThe Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryGeologic Time
Minerals by PropertiesMinerals by ChemistryAdvanced Locality SearchRandom MineralRandom LocalitySearch by minIDLocalities Near MeSearch ArticlesSearch GlossaryMore Search Options
The Mindat ManualAdd a New PhotoRate PhotosLocality Edit ReportCoordinate Completion ReportAdd Glossary Item
Mining CompaniesStatisticsUsersMineral MuseumsClubs & OrganizationsMineral Shows & EventsThe Mindat DirectoryDevice SettingsThe Mineral Quiz
Photo SearchPhoto GalleriesSearch by ColorNew Photos TodayNew Photos YesterdayMembers' Photo GalleriesPast Photo of the Day GalleryPhotography
╳Discussions
💬 Home🔎 Search📅 LatestGroups
EducationOpen discussion area.Fakes & FraudsOpen discussion area.Field CollectingOpen discussion area.FossilsOpen discussion area.Gems and GemologyOpen discussion area.GeneralOpen discussion area.How to ContributeOpen discussion area.Identity HelpOpen discussion area.Improving Mindat.orgOpen discussion area.LocalitiesOpen discussion area.Lost and Stolen SpecimensOpen discussion area.MarketplaceOpen discussion area.MeteoritesOpen discussion area.Mindat ProductsOpen discussion area.Mineral ExchangesOpen discussion area.Mineral PhotographyOpen discussion area.Mineral ShowsOpen discussion area.Mineralogical ClassificationOpen discussion area.Mineralogy CourseOpen discussion area.MineralsOpen discussion area.Minerals and MuseumsOpen discussion area.PhotosOpen discussion area.Techniques for CollectorsOpen discussion area.The Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryOpen discussion area.UV MineralsOpen discussion area.Recent Images in Discussions
Mineral ShowsQuestion for Dealers: Thefts at Shows
3rd May 2010 05:10 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
3rd May 2010 06:01 UTCJake Harper Expert
Cheers,
Jake
3rd May 2010 06:04 UTCDana Slaughter 🌟 Expert
I've had very few problems that I know of to be honest. I don't police my booth as much as some dealers do and I'm very relaxed about having people come back behind the tables and have a look around. I worry more about my cash box than anything else. I've had three instances in many years that I know of: a) another dealer took some things b) a cameraman and mobile reporter took a mammoth tooth and fossil whale vertebra--I guess that they thought that it should be free as I was the one being put on TV! and c) one inexpensive item came up missing. We get very busy on our first day of the shows and my wife and I are sometimes overrun by customers waiting to pay. While we're busy wrapping, etc. it would be very easy for someone to pocket something---I'm sometimes amazed that it doesn't happen more often. Others will point out empty boxes in flats but invariably it is because someone put the rock back in the wrong spot.
I generally have the more expensive items in glass cases near the back. I did have one other dealer try to scam my sons while I used the restroom. Fortunately, my sons didn't bite and the guy was beside himself trying to explain how he thought I told him that he could get 60% off a specimen that was already reasonably priced. He turned beet red and I've never seen him again.
I regularly hear about theft at just about every show that I've done but usually it is jewelry items that are stolen. One guy at a show in MI tried to run off with a big oreodont skull in matrix from SD (not mine) and got about 30 yards before being caught. What a moron. I figure that I have to expect at least some theft but I've been pleasantly surprised at how little theft we've encountered. Maybe I'm too relaxed and just don't realize it! There may have been one or two other instances but I can't honestly remember any others at the moment.
I bought a huge collection in 2007 and in 2008 we brought the collection to our best show in Mesa, AZ (A.L. Flagg Gem and Mineral Show) and we were swamped by customers about 1/2 hour before we opened. They were lifting the sides of our tent to get in! We probably had 15-20 people waiting to pay and just the two of us were manning our double booth that year. It is the only time that I've ever really been worried about theft--I couldn't help but think how our backs were turned for virtually the entire first couple hours. The next year we had a friend stop by for a while to keep an eye on things while we wrapped, boxed and bagged but we weren't nearly so frantic as the year before so it wasn't a problem.
Fortunately, one of my buddies has a booth next to mine and we take turns watching each other's stuff every now and again so that we can check something out or use the restroom, etc. Good question!
Best regards,
Dana
6th May 2010 10:13 UTCAlfredo Petrov Manager
6th May 2010 13:44 UTCDavid Weiss
and while I know it wasn't your intention, the statement below could be interpreteted as eletist or snobby.
Alfredo Petrov Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> A personal observation is that the higher the
> entrance charge for buyers, the less theft there
> seems to be. Lot less theft at the Munich show,
> which has a rather steep entrance fee, than at
> free-of-charge venues in Tucson. A stiff entrance
> fee discourages some lowlife types but not the
> serious customers. (Caveat: I have no statistics
> for this, just personal experience, no
> statistically significant sample size.)
6th May 2010 14:31 UTCMaryanne Fender
6th May 2010 16:19 UTCScott Sadlocha
I was really curious about it at the Greater Detroit Show this year. The venue changed to a Trade Center/Flea Market location, rather than a local community college, and I found the new location very unappealing, not to mention I saw a great of less than savory looking characters in the area, and the access into and out of the show seemed more plentiful, which to me seemed a bad situation.
I heard that there were quite a few thefts at the Cincinnati, Ohio show about a week ago. Can anyone confirm this?
6th May 2010 16:55 UTCChris Stefano Expert
6th May 2010 17:05 UTCScott Sadlocha
6th May 2010 17:21 UTCChris Stefano Expert
6th May 2010 18:28 UTCDonald Slater
10th May 2010 06:02 UTCJohn Attard Expert
You bring up a good point that is it amazes you that someone would find a mineral specimen enjoyable when they know they stole it. I would say they may think at that time they would but later it probably turns out they do not ... especially when they realize that because if it they are now a thief.
In general for me theft is not a major issue but I take the precaution of putting the most valuable minerals behind glass.
10th May 2010 08:31 UTCGreg Dainty
We average 1 to 2 thefts a show. Im pretty sure mostly its kids, we have caught a couple. Its almost always the price tag that attracts them, i.e " that little things worth $100, wow" . What really gets to me is, they very rarely take the associated information label, so mostly they have no idea what they have taken. Theft of specimens by somebody with good mineral knowledge, Id say is probably one specimen a year.
What do you do? pay particular attention to groups of young kids.(13 - 14 years old plus), especially if they have been,to your stand once or twice earlier, put really valuable pieces at the rear, concentrated in one area, pay particular attention in the last one or two hours of a show.
I know this sounds a bit harsh on kids , but this is our experience. .......Greg
10th May 2010 17:30 UTCAlfredo Petrov Manager
10th May 2010 17:53 UTCChris Stefano Expert
10th May 2010 18:20 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
If my five-year losses to theft are on $75, then I can count myself as very lucky. Haven't had a bad check or problematic credit card yet.
I have, over the years, 'stared away' (chased away by staring) suspicious kids, teenagers, and middle-aged ladies with large handbags. Even had to stare away another dealer once.
10th May 2010 18:50 UTCMark Gottlieb
10th May 2010 18:59 UTCTom Klinepeter
10th May 2010 21:01 UTCAnonymous User
10th May 2010 22:53 UTCDenise Bicknell
10th May 2010 23:06 UTCMark Gottlieb
10th May 2010 23:41 UTCMaggie Wilson Expert
We've been lucky enough to have only minor breakage and no thefts. We sell thumbnails in their perky boxes - the ones placed toward the front of the table are most at risk - inquisitive fingers (mostly kids) are the greatest concern. And who but the most knowledgeable is able to resist the urge to reach out toward the shiny, pretty, exotic looking pieces? We've also had to speak out to the folks that want to handle the pieces to gauge the energy.
To prevent breakage, we try to remain vigilant, and we elevate the table - see this thread http://www.mindat.org/mesg-64-178798.html We keep a stool on hand for those that need the extra height to view the pieces.
Maggie
11th May 2010 00:11 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
11th May 2010 00:14 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
And don't even get me started as to my policies when the heelies put a specimen into a body cavity..... Lucky for me the obnoxious woman who put a $50 Brazilian schorl deep into her cleavage "to test the energy" did buy it. She was going to buy it, whether she wanted to or not, after it went there.
11th May 2010 00:24 UTCPeter Hargis
At shows, I will walk the show first to see what's available and then return to certain tables numerous times trying to make up my mind, so I too try to look as innocent as possible b/c I know this can be suspicious. I usually keep my hands clasped behind my back while I'm looking at a dealer's minerals. And if the mineral looks fragile, I will ask the dealer if I may pick it up or if he/she can pick it up for me. It hurts to have to buy a broken mineral as much, I assume, as it does to have one broken in your inventory.
11th May 2010 02:11 UTCSteve Hardinger 🌟 Expert
11th May 2010 02:18 UTCScott Sadlocha
I agree with you. I pretty much follow the same procedure as I walk around shows, including the hands behind the back as I lean over. In the colder months, when I wear a coat, it becomes more troublesome, as I always get too warm at some point, so I am then carrying around a coat, and whatever I purchased, and it can get unweildy.
11th May 2010 16:32 UTCStephen Rose Expert
Cheers!
Steve
11th May 2010 17:33 UTCDavid Weiss
The next year I walked in with a button down shirt and slacks, and the dealers seemed more attentive. One even handed me a $100 specimen and turned his back to take care of another customer.
...Which means he either trusted me, or the specimen wasn't worth the price tag. :)
Also, I found that the people dressed in nicer cloths have a harder time negotiating price with dealers. :)
But, yea, I do the hands behind the back thing too.
Peter Hargis Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> At shows, I will walk the show first to see what's
> available and then return to certain tables
> numerous times trying to make up my mind, so I too
> try to look as innocent as possible b/c I know
> this can be suspicious. I usually keep my hands
> clasped behind my back while I'm looking at a
> dealer's minerals.
4th Jul 2010 19:27 UTCRachel Cesana
The Rhode Island Mineral Hunters run a show in RI at the Community College and we have not had any significant theft there. We hire a Security guard to walk around and our members walk around as well to help out. Our dealers say they are happy with us walking around as a second set of eyes for them or for bathroom breaks. jewelry seems to be the biggest draw for thefts not the high end stuff though. Vigilence seems to be the biggist deterrent and by everyone involved in the show.
Rach
5th Jul 2010 02:15 UTCVik Vanrusselt Expert
However, I'm in a wheelchair (I'm handicapped, Spina Bifida to be exact) and always have a large backpack attached to it, containing spare clothing and stuff I might need. For some reason, that makes me suspicious to EVERYONE at a show.
I can see people thinking "He's faking it, that backpack is stuffed with things he's already stolen..."
(The most annoying thing to me however at mineral shows is not theft/breakage (which I have been accused of a few times, JUST because I'm in a wheelchair so I MUST be dangerous), but the 'selfishness' of the visitors. Some people even deliberately step in front of me at every single stand. When I accidentally hit their heels with my wheelchair they turn around and flip out at first, then apologize in the most ridiculous ways for not noticing me, which in turn is hilarious to me!)
13th Jul 2010 01:51 UTCGeoffrey Krasnov Expert
What is difficult to control are the hands of the urchins. Parents seem to think it is so cute when they pick up specimens and rub the nice okenite ball. We have to constantly remind them to "touch with your eyes". Naturally, all the lesser priced and less fragile pieces populate the table peripheries, and the better stuff goes in cases.
All in all, the losses are way lower than retailers experience in general. I like to believe that people in the mineral hobby are just that much more honest and friendly. In all my years I have never had a bounced check either.
8th Sep 2010 06:14 UTCAisha Jan
The most expensive specimen, an $ 8000.00 Paprok Tourmaline crystal, was lifted, in Tucson at the Inn Suites in 2008. The crystal was in a closed but not locked case. A couple of 'buyers' wanted to take photographs of our minerals. While one asked us to hold a specimen he was interested in, while he photographed it, the other helped himself to the Tourmaline crystal. A police report was filed, but no results as yet. That year, many dealers in Tucson at the Inn Suites were robbed.
We have now attached bells to the door of the shut cases. If anyone opens it, the ring of the bell gets our attention even if we are very busy. Additionally, we now install security cameras in all room locations & if the room gets too crowded, we request some to wait before entering. We also discourage photography, EXCEPT when Jolyon Ralph visits. His visits are always welcomed. A security advisor informed us that most thieves will photograph fine minerals to offer to buyers, before attempting theft.
Talking about old ladies with open bags....One came to my booth at a convention center show. She picked up a huge piece of rough Lapis & threw it into her bag. She hit the little dog on the head that was asleep in her bag, who woke up yelping! I noticed the Lapis was gone, called security, who discovered that she had been on a free shopping spree at the show. She was duly arrested
8th Sep 2010 20:13 UTCRay Hill Expert
BUT NOW I fear that I might have to rethink this , since I have read in more than one entry that thieves photograph stuff they plan to steal and I don't want to be suspected of being one of those..
My only saving grace may be that I am now a familiar figure and I do the same thing at every show and every museum I attend...
THANK YOU, TO ALL YOU DEALERS THAT HAVE PERMITTED ME TO TAKE HOME THEIR SPECIMENS ON FILM!!
8th Sep 2010 20:32 UTCAlfredo Petrov Manager
Theft of specimens at shows is opportunistic, by definition something that is hard to plan. A thief who photographs specimens for the purpose of offering them to clients... Huh? How does he know the specimen will still be there, and available to grab, when he comes back? Why take the risk of being recognized? It makes little sense. But I may well be wrong, and I won't complain if someone proves me wrong, but it had better be a first hand account and not just some hearsay ""It happened to a friend..." type of story, after which I'll still be a sceptic.
9th Sep 2010 13:55 UTCAisha Jan
I personally doubt that the reason for the photography is to come back and lift the specimen, but from experience, I do know that it can be used as a distraction.....as in our case.
Besides being advised by security experts who have nothing to do with the mineral industry, a show promoter
at the 2009 Tucson show (after many dealers were robbed in 2008) circulated a memo, advising dealers not to allow photography.
When we attempted to follow this rule, a visitor to our room became extremely agitated, threatened to run for the office of the Mayor to fight this rule.
We allow photography by everyone known to us and by those who request permission. For those that take it for granted, permission is granted or politely declined, depending on the situation in our room at the time,
Cheers!
Aisha & Arif Jan
9th Sep 2010 17:42 UTCAnonymous User
Recently at the small local shows I've been to I have noticed a ban on photography. I assumed it was because dealers don't want anyone to copy their setups or displays.
This year at the big Breeder's Expo in Daytona (the "Tucson" of the reptile industry) a very expensive gecko was stolen from a table. (If you've never been to such a show, most animals are in deli cups.) It was close to a grand, I believe. Animals in this price range (and they go much higher) are bought almost exclusively by other breeders who see them as an investment (baby-makers). So the chances that it was stolen by a middle-aged lady or a scruffy kid are slim. My point is that surely in every hobby there are knowledgeable people who will stoop to theft.
Personally I never tried to touch an okenite. I may have done some unintentional injury to a millerite, though.
9th Sep 2010 19:34 UTCTimothy Greenland
Cheers
Tim
10th Sep 2010 01:01 UTCPhil Mesa
I always ask to take photos, but normally of stuff under locked display cabinets. And I only do this if there is a low presence of customers at the booth/room.
10th Sep 2010 15:22 UTCJason Evans
I told the head teacher and i remeber us all being in his office and the teacher asked why he stole it and the excuse was becuase he was jealous of it, well i didnt get puched, just shovbe up agaisnt the wall but it was worth it to see him humilated and having to give it back to my freind.
after a while we kinda forgot about it and then one day this individul came round my house, and my freind was there as well, the idiot stole some of my specimens whilst i went to the toilet, right in front of my freind and said the same thing to him, if he told he was going to get punched.
he actually didnt tell, instead did something far more amsuing, we went out for a bit and when we were coming back my freind said he was deperate for the loo so ran ahead, and he quickly "re-stole" my minerals from the culprits bag and hid them somewhere until he was gone then he told me what happened, and the funniest thing was the idiot didnt even guess what happejed becuase the next day apprently he said to my freind, those mineral i stiole were gone out of my bag when i got home, he was quite confused how that happened!
I had the last laugh though, in saying this i hope i dont give the impresion that i am a theif, but this individual brought some garnet in schist in to show us, and whikle i was looking at it the lesson bell rang, the persosn just grabbed his bag and ran off to get to the lesson, leaving me with his garnet still in my hand, and no he never got it back, a few hours later he was all annoyed he lost his garnet, we even helped him look for it knowing it was in my locker.
I now know that was not a nice thing to do but at the time i justified it as not stealing it becuase he just left it in my hands and forgot about it, and also i felt like it was only fair as he had stolen from both of us.
17th Sep 2010 01:22 UTCChris Foltz
22nd Sep 2010 18:51 UTCEzekiel Hughes
28th Sep 2010 04:19 UTCRonald Kendig
My wife and I have been show dealers for nearly 30 years. We have seen some specimens "disappear" over the years, and we find no common denominator as to who, when or at what show that it will happen. The first specimen we ever had taken was in Bufallo NY when a showy Pyrite crystal disappeared after a little, old, white-haired lady had been in the area (and she disappeared from the show shortly afterwards.) You just never know who to suspect.
For many years at the Northern Berkshire Club's show, there was a heavy-set American Indian woman in a wheelchair. A couple years, she was spotted stealing and called on it. She acted like she didn't know the specimens dropped into the folds of her blanket. The dealers believed her and were just happy to get their specimens back. She would hang around a show all day, and chatted with dealers and customers.
Whenever we suspect someone, we spread the word to other dealers. It is only polite to do so and I would hope that other dealers would have the same courtesy. That way there are several sets of eyes watching.
There are two habitual mineral thieves whom we have not been able to catch 'in the act'. They both have established rapports with dealers by buying, but steal from other dealers. One man is from upstate New York. We nicknamed him "squeaky" because he has a high squeaky voice; he is one very slick operator and works in tandem with two friends. My wife literally cringes every time we see him. We used to go to the Rochester Symposium (NY) where dealers sell out of their rooms. Every year we lost at least one high price specimen to this guy (finding the empty box after he left the room). We even had 4 sets of eyes watching him, but he still managed to take something without our seeing it. One year we brought an enclosed case to deter specifically him; we heard the thump on the case as he tried to reach into the back of the case. He could not see the case was totally enclosed. Red faced, he quickly left the room. Another year, we saw the "end signal, the tip of the hat"; when we approached the floor guard, he refused to frisk them. We were told unless we caught the guy in the act, there was nothing he could do; symposium personnel agreed. We no longer go there.
The other man used to buy and take at Pennsylvania shows. He wore a tan fishing vest with many bulging pockets. He drove a car with Delaware plates. No one ever caught him in the act, but dealers always complained of expensive specimens missing. He likes smaller pieces, like thumbnails and micromounts. He has a rapport with several dealers who think he is wonderful.
There are various types of thieves: there are those who steal outright at shows; those who steal from mineral collections, and those who steal by bogus transactions:
We were just at the Franklin, NJ Show this past weekend. I was pleased to hear an announcement to the dealers prior to the opening of the show. We were warned of a specific man who portrays himself as a retired U.S. Navy Colonel, who is known for being in a hurry and buying heavily from many dealers. But his checks bounce and his credit cards are bogus. There are warrants out for his arrest in many areas. We were unfortunate at the Monroe NY show this past June to meet him, and yes, we got taken by a bogus credit card. I recently learned another dealer lost over $400.00 at the same show, accepted a check from him.
Summary: go get them, pursue legal action, don't let them get away with taking anything.
Mindat.org is an outreach project of the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy, a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: April 19, 2024 03:55:28
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: April 19, 2024 03:55:28