Log InRegister
Quick Links : The Mindat ManualThe Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryMindat Newsletter [Free Download]
Home PageAbout MindatThe Mindat ManualHistory of MindatCopyright StatusWho We AreContact UsAdvertise on Mindat
Donate to MindatCorporate SponsorshipSponsor a PageSponsored PagesMindat AdvertisersAdvertise on Mindat
Learning CenterWhat is a mineral?The most common minerals on earthInformation for EducatorsMindat ArticlesThe ElementsThe Rock H. Currier Digital LibraryGeologic Time
Minerals by PropertiesMinerals by ChemistryAdvanced Locality SearchRandom MineralRandom LocalitySearch by minIDLocalities Near MeSearch ArticlesSearch GlossaryMore Search Options
Search For:
Mineral Name:
Locality Name:
Keyword(s):
 
The Mindat ManualAdd a New PhotoRate PhotosLocality Edit ReportCoordinate Completion ReportAdd Glossary Item
Mining CompaniesStatisticsUsersMineral MuseumsClubs & OrganizationsMineral Shows & EventsThe Mindat DirectoryDevice SettingsThe Mineral Quiz
Photo SearchPhoto GalleriesSearch by ColorNew Photos TodayNew Photos YesterdayMembers' Photo GalleriesPast Photo of the Day GalleryPhotography

Techniques for Collectorsrock breakers / trimmers

19th Apr 2013 11:52 UTCJames Jones

Hi,


I need to purchase two types of rock breakers and would appreciate any advice and assistance. I need one to break and trim small pieces of rock that contain very fragile crystals and another to break larger rocks that also will contain fragile crystals. In other words, I'd be first breaking the larger rocks down to smaller segments and then trimming these smaller pieces into fragments maybe to as little as 1/2 x 1/2 inch, or even smaller.


Also, I need a decent 6 to 6.5 inch dry cut trim saw blade with 1/2 inch arbor. I need it to be somewhat thin, but not ultra thin, especially as it is not a motor driven feed, but hand held during cutting.. And, it won't be cutting anything hard, such as granite. The rock is pretty soft as rocks go.


Thanks for input.

19th Apr 2013 14:36 UTCBob Harman

01481690016016016947107.jpg
JAMES , Pictured here are my 2 trimmers. The first picture is of a small c-clamp trimmer mounted on a wood plank for stability. It was given to me; I would not buy nor recommend one of this type. It will split rock up to about 1" thick. So it is of quite limited use and only for thin or soft, easily split rock. I use it only on easily trimmed rock with non delicate crystals as it can break easily cleaved or delicate crystals, damaging or destroying the specimen.


The second picture is of my larger trimmer. It uses a 6 ton hydraulic jack mounted on a steel stabilizer frame as shown. The blade gap is easily changed with a key that releases jack pressure and is then tightened. The whole set up is about 27" high and 20" wide. The carbon steel blades are quite good, but the drawback with this trimmer is that the blades do not come together. So it will cut rock from 1 1/2" thick to about 6" thick, but not thinner slabs. Sudden fly rock chips are a real possibility so I cover the whole set up with a terry towel as it it gets ready to trim the specimen. The set up was made by a metal fabricating company and it is on loan to me by a collector friend. Hope this helps...................CHEERS.............BOB
04358210015999390484116.jpg

19th Apr 2013 17:41 UTCEugene & Sharon Cisneros Expert

Here is a previous discussion regarding trimmers that may be useful. Trimmers


Gene

19th Apr 2013 18:19 UTCBart Cannon

I have not seen the previous discussions on this subeject, but I will mention that Zuber makes a reliable heavy duty oil based hydraulic trimmer and a reliable purely mechanical thumbnail trimmer. I have been using both for 25 years with zero problems.


I don't know what company made it, but the world's best rock trimmer may still reside in the basement of the Cranbrook Institute of Science in Bloomfiled Hills Michigan. That was my first mineral job back in 1962. Trimming minerals for their sales counter.


I am going to contact them immediately. In those days my best friend was Chester A. Hard, and his mother was Anita Hard, the museum director. She is certaiinly long gone,


Chester Hard and I would take winter birding trips. The bird lists we obtained were my first science publications. We thought we observed a gyrfalcon. Chester recorded the exact time we observed each bird species. Cold and snowy days in the hills North of Detroit..


There is yet another trimmer option. A mining company's diamond drill core splitter. Mine has fantasic square threads for jawing down on the specimen. The mechanism is attached to the "stearring wheel" control. I keep mine outdoors. It can handle large rocks and is completely indestructable and works just fine with rocks of any shape..


Once a specimn is in its jaws, you crank down with the "steering wheel" and then tap down on the shaft with a hammer. BINGO. The rock breaks. Sometimes you can get these for $15.


Bart

19th Apr 2013 18:27 UTCDean Allum Expert

James,

This topic comes up periodically on Mindat. Here is another thread:

http://www.mindat.org/forum.php?read,19,255330,255558,quote=1


I just purchased the Meister trimmer and will attest that it is excellent for small volumes of precision trimming.


Regards,

Dean Allum

19th Apr 2013 20:44 UTCPaul Brandes 🌟 Manager

03809700016016016941666.jpg
Here is a photo of my rock breaker. Been with me over 14 years and not one malfunction.

Capable of breaking and trimming rocks the size of an automobile to thumbnails in a matter of minutes....... :-D


19th Apr 2013 20:51 UTCJames Jones

Thanks for the input.


I especially need something that will break the small samples into those piece that could be .5 x .5 inches or so, yet do it without having pieces fly everywhere.


And, it needs to be accurate in its trimming and gentle. That is, not something that has a more crushing type break as opposed to a line fracture type thing, if you get my drift. I'll be trying to trim things that I can barely see the pocket, much less the crystals within!

19th Apr 2013 20:53 UTCJames Jones

Paul,


What in the image is the rock breaker, and which one hasn't malfunctioned as of yet? ;-)

19th Apr 2013 23:47 UTCPaul Brandes 🌟 Manager

Both and neither, James! :-D

I believe this same photo was used by Gail Spann for her presentation in Tucson a few months ago.


In all seriousness though, I have to echo Bart's suggestion and recommend the Zuber. It is a great machine for trimming specimens and while they tend to be a little on the pricey side, they are a strong, quality piece of machinery. Another suggestion is an automotive arbor press you can purchase at Harbor Freight, Northern Tool, etc. You can get them in several sizes to suit your job and if needed, you can fabricate a cage around the contact points to catch anything that might explode off.

20th Apr 2013 00:10 UTCJohn Oostenryk

Bob,

That second picture you show- Anybody able to give details on said unit's origin?

(edited- This is a Ward's Scientific Model) ( See separate post about re-engineering return springs-fixes Bob's problem!)

Our geology dept has the EXACT same vintage unit as Bob shows but with a different spring return setup.

Bart,
Where would I look/search for a used core splitter? The device you describe sounds exactly like what my professor wants(then I could have the hydraulic!)
What is the biggest opening dimension?



Very Ironic- Our geology dept units are in the back of my truck right now, headed back to the process lab! I brought them home to tune up. This was totally broke down, and another (different setup) unit had died also. Each having issues from too much grit and old dried gooey grease/oil had both gummed up horribly, the jack was low on fluid, and worst, on the Ward's, the slide assembly nuts were loose(1.5") The major issue, someone had tack welded the spacing collars- and one was way off(IDIOT!)... This had nothing to do with original manufacturer...


Anyhoo- I fixed all that and ran a bunch of specimens thorugh it to verify the repairs. Oh it is a champ! I want one sooo bad!


So Ironically- I made the rounds just this morning of the internet for all the trimmer sites again since needing my own... (Edit follows)

Attard's Minerals,

Absolute Clarity and Calibration,

Ward's Scientific,

Mikon for Zuber,

I was looking at opening sizes... The ACC units look to be very high quality screw operations- check em out for small stuff, as others have noted.

I have been very impressed with the Ward's unit on size of opening and utilization. Works like a champ-IMHO!!!

Even NEW- is way cheaper than big Zuber, and appears to me to be easier to operate! I'd say get one!)-edit done


James- I just got done shearing a LOT of heavy dolomite matrix with tabular barites - it went smooth. Funny how that sharp pop is not destructive- I always cringe- and they look great.

For all work, I hold the specimen when I am splitting. Big stuff, I am grippng one handed th piece I want, other side falIs to back... Or I block up and towel/foam cushion either one or both sides.

For Finer Work- have the specimen cupped in my hand. Thumb and 2 fingers on better (front half) at front of chisel. Then chisel comes up between 2 finger and back two finger, which are supporting back portion... I wear gloves-and glasses- the thing is already pinched, so can't "get" your hand! Grip both sides at same time one handed- run pump with the other. No 'flying' specimens!

Usually, post split- I don't move my gripping hand. I use pump hand to release pressure so jack moves away and I can see and move safely what I got... It's very natural and easy to do...


As to size- that rock in my pic is now 1/4 original size- Ordovician dolomite- plenty dense~ I cut it in half (against the grain) boom! Then I split it in half again-very slow gentle application -with the layering- and kinda crunnnch/pop---presto!

There's my biggest yet, Dubuque Iowa barite. I could see it through a lil hole into the vug wall. Luckily it was not attached to both sides(top and bottom-thus getting tore in half on opening-eek~! Instead it was Oh YES!:)

(I found this on my b-day 3 weeks ago) but wasn't going to hammer it(to pieces!)


Good luck deciding on a unit- you are gonna love the process when you get one:)


~JO:)


ps: Go Natalie Brandes!! Wish I had a partner who could run a sledge~:) Rock on!

20th Apr 2013 02:48 UTCJohn Wilda (2)

Try Absolute Clarity out of CT. They make 2 sizes. The small one is only $85. and is great for thumbnails and micros.

20th Apr 2013 07:16 UTCJohn Oostenryk

04323260016016016946813.jpg
James- I'm sorry, I meant to have inquired prior as to your specimen materials and second half of your tool question? I was already rattled by the potentially timely topic and then Bob's pic, as I had said... I apologize for the pseudo hijack there:)


More importantly- What is the material you are trimming?

You seem to have something in mind. Knowing what you need/want for equipment is good, but the other half of your inquiry, successful processing? Being vague doesn't inspire help.

Surely better direction/assistance will be provided if YOU take time to share the matrix type and potential minerals.

Sed/Ign/Meta matrix? Cobbles, Layered/bedded, or 'massive'? Breccia? Too many variables left open-


As to your sawing: Sounds like you want a trim blade on a hand held angle grinder. STOP- KEEP IN MIND the ROTATION Speed!


Lapidary saw motors are typically ~1725 rpm. The blades can be made thin because of low speed and superior oil COOLING.

An electric handheld grinder is easily in the 10,000 rpm range! High Cetrifugal force and only air cooling make for high heat.
Your trimsaw blade WILL come apart at those speeds and slice deep into you!

I am not being 'dramatic'- it is simple physics and expensively gruesome/traumatic!


DRY Diamond blades are thick for a reason- high speed and heat resistance! The intermittent diamond media is a 'rougher' cut but aids cooling. You can get a continuous rim for wet tile - still a high speed application-so thicker than lapidary.


Be aware that diamond blades are NOT all the same- The diamonds are- but the MEDIA holding them is NOT. Be sure to get a blade suited/rated for the hardness of the material- anything with quartz/chalcedony in it is death for a regular dry blade.

If you are seeing steady bright sparks- STOP- you are killing your blade.


If you need direction/opinion on blade types/applications/source- you need to list what you are driving it with: Tool type or motor and its Make/Model/ rpm.


One further note for success! You said blade for hand held 'cutter'. If you are doing the 'saw trimming' with a hand held grinder- do this!

Put it in a vise with the switch in ON position. Plug the cord into a power strip/switched box right there. Then plug that 'switch' into an extension cord or wherever. The idea is to have the blade stationary, and hold the sample. Bring the sample(with both hands:) to the blade! Gives great control- can be done very reliably- I have cut hundreds of samples for days using that method.

Because-

Rocks are never uniform shapes- to try to clamp them? Pew-there they go! - Power tools always jump at start, and twist while running wears you out (not to mention binding issues??)-and when you stop, you have to wait for blade to quit turning or zing! something...! all BAD for rock sample and you!


On Vise use: Ideal is a 'chain vise'. I use a 3legged portable stand, I have a 7" blade on a 4.5 inch grinder.

Note the power switch box I made for cheap. I prefer this as lightswitch is easier to hit than on a 'power strip.'



You can get just the vise part and screw it to a table/sawhorse/stump etc. (sawhorse should be staked or weighted down.)
02406640015999390493781.jpg



It is possible to use a regular jaw vise- just get something to grip the round grinder body more uniformly in flat opposing jaws. Consider how pic applies-vise jaw inserts for round body - can do similar with wood.
02617150015999390498292.jpg




Whichever vise you use- DO NOT OVERTIGHTEN- you can easily squish the body and/or bind the spinning internals-all bad:)

Also be mindful of any vents in unit- blocking them can burn up unit.


Wear a halfmask respirator. The 3M disposables with the vent in center are great and last a long while. I prefer my rubber halfmask version w/ replaceable filters- comfy and efficient- worth every penny of my good health- no cut corners-don't be foolish.

Earplugs- oh just do it- Save your hearing-you will miss it!

Gloves- diamond won't cut skin fast like a wood blade(ack-ghastly)leaves an abrasion/burn. BUT- it will take off the harder fingernail instantly- and that IS what pokes out more. Trust me- I know it sux;)

+++++++


Do keep in mind that bit about the more initial detail an info seeker is willing to give, the better the return.

Also please consider adding your country location to your personal info. It helps to know where someone is as to their familiarity and access with products and vendors:)

Hope this info above helps~ I've been planning an article about just such a setup for a while-this is the quickie version.

Good luck in your endeavors- let us know how it comes out~post pics!

~JO:)

20th Apr 2013 12:35 UTCLuca Baralis Expert

To trim (very) little sample, I often use a tile pincer. It is fast and quite accurate, but I'm looking for something safer for my fingers...

21st Apr 2013 14:17 UTCBart Cannon

I will blather on about this subject since I have forty years of experience.


The Zuber thumbnail trimmer is many times faster than any "C clamp" trimmer. One can divide a specimen in one second.


I obtained both of my Zubers from the late, beloved Harvey Gordon. I traded Vesper Peak Garnets to ge them.


I converted a Home Depot miter saw into a diamond blade chop saw. Works like a dream once you install a water pump with an articulating water spigot.


For trimming slabs I use an Ameritool mini slab saw which I modified to accept a six inch blade and built an adjustable race or fence to facilitate the slab width. The Ameritool trim saw has a strong motor and a molded plastic housing which, of course, never rusts.


I don't know if Zuber of Ameritool are still in business.


John Li of Portland Oregon based Wydar had exact duplicates made of the Zuber hydraulic rock breaker which he had made in China. I don't know if he is still in business.


Bart

23rd Apr 2013 19:19 UTCJohn Oostenryk

I have edited some of my first reply on this topic about trimmers.


but more importantly...

Bart, I never find any blather in your postings, just lots of cool details and inspiration:) Thanks always!

Any chance you could post the max opening size of your core splitter, please? Estimation is fine...
Even better, Pics of your mechanical improvements would be REALLY Cool! Please, please?

Sincerely,

~JO:)


ps: I certainly don't mind useful pics of used (dirty?)equipment- no cleanup necessary!!!

(This isn't the OCD-help forum, right?lol) ...although I suspect you keep stuff pretty spiffy:)

23rd Dec 2015 00:27 UTCP. Bigos

05638190016016016949161.jpg
I see there is mention here about Wydar splitters. I am looking into hydraulic specimen trimmers too. Anybody have any clue what the going price on a used Wydar trimer labelled US PATENT 5638805 all painted yellow with a "4x5" should be? Does anybody know much about the trimmer I have pictured here? Is this an old model? Was this made in USA? I keep hearing people saying Wydar was made in China. Anybody know what these went for 15-20 years ago? I'm assuming this may be when this was originally purchased.


01701480015659332943185.jpg

02525460015659332949139.jpg

23rd Dec 2015 20:13 UTCJohn Oostenryk

Hello P.,

I can't speak directly about the trimmer type you ask about~ have not used or handled one. Couple thoughts about used units, though.


Seeing my post above, it has been 2.5 years now since I purchased a Ward's large model for $600. (Used-like new)

This was a later manufacture unit, improved from their earliest ones. Mine has coil springs around the guide shafts, and bolt on, brass lined guide sleeves.The chisel tips were both in good shape, not factory sharp, but lots of edge still for bite, and they are still in good shape after chopping a LOT of sedimentary material!


The Ward's unit uses two opposing chisels, kinda snipper in theory and action. Focused Pinch on two thin lines directs and instigates propagation of the split/break. I have great success with that.

My lil 'concern' with the unit you picture, "Does it have a second chisel to replace the flat base shown?"

If not, it is not "snipping' so much as driving a chisel in on one side because bottom is not on a chisel edge. This may result in more occasions of what I call a blowout, instead of a break (through). Blow out is where instead of shearing through- the material breaks off in a wedge shape extending to weakest nearby area. That is not desirable.


Point two I would verify- Is that chisel dull/rounded. Pic makes it look pretty rough? The ones I have are HARD, as in hardened. While you can likely burn through the hardness to sharpen,then the edge is not as hard and will dull faster. Something to consider~

If you got a good 'smith around, they may be able to sharpen and then use heat treat tech to reharden

Or see if you can buy replacemnet tips. Do the Zuber tips fit it?


If you are planning on chewing harder materials- maybe used tips aren't as big a deal- as they will wear faster anyway? and need repair then...


All I can say - I love my trimmer! I have used older model like mine, with blunter tips, not quite as precision or concise, and pops with greater pressure~ but still very functional and useable.

24th Dec 2015 12:31 UTCGary Moldovany

I have two of these type trimmers. One is the small unit I purchased from Attard's Minerals a few years ago. Don't try to break anything big with this unit, I managed to snap one of the chisels on a hard piece of NJ basalt. Fortunately the unit came with extra chisels. It's the Wydar trimmer "forged in China". I have a much larger unit that was sold by a local collector to me a few months ago, but I believe it was specially made for the previous owner in a machine shop. It is a screw type that will break up to a 4" thickness. One tip I can suggest: I used my diamond wheel grinder to cut a groove in the top and bottom of the rock where I wanted the break to occur. This helped the chisels to bite into the rock much better, especially on an odd-shaped specimen.

5th Jan 2016 12:43 UTCDale Foster Manager

I bought one of these last year: Cornwall Rock Trimmers


A brilliant bit of kit for the money.
 
Mineral and/or Locality  
Mindat Discussions Facebook Logo Instagram Logo Discord Logo
Mindat.org is an outreach project of the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy, a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.
Copyright © mindat.org and the Hudson Institute of Mineralogy 1993-2024, except where stated. Most political location boundaries are © OpenStreetMap contributors. Mindat.org relies on the contributions of thousands of members and supporters. Founded in 2000 by Jolyon Ralph.
Privacy Policy - Terms & Conditions - Contact Us / DMCA issues - Report a bug/vulnerability Current server date and time: April 26, 2024 10:08:45
Go to top of page